Ys

Seer of ghosts & weaver of stories

(You are very much not forgotten)

Previous Entry Share Next Entry
December Blogging Meme Topics #16 & #17
Ys
ajodasso
Are there things that will always make you back away when reading a story?
miss_morland

Are there things that are guaranteed to make you keep reading a story?
jb_slasher

On the first count, character-torture for no reason other than to be gratuitously cruel to both characters and readers turns me right off. I won't stand for it, especially not when those characters have already been through enough. If the hardship doesn't result in significant character growth or demonstrable benefit to the plot, forget it, I'm out. I have a hard time with gaslighting, but I can't remember the last time I put something down solely because it was there (again: if character and plot development result, chances are I'll stay). I have an easier time reading descriptions of certain kinds of graphic violence than I do watching depictions of same, although there are some varieties I can't even read about (bone injuries don't go over well).

The two other reliable turn-offs, I guess, are a) overwrought prose that's condescending to the reader and b) poor grasp of grammar and spelling. And, yes, I do take ability, age, education level, and experience into account. The the more clues I have that the writer in question should know better, the less I can abide glaring technical errors.

Otherwise, what will keep me reading depends entirely on how the writer handles, well, everything in a given piece. I'm aware that's probably far too open-ended an answer for anyone's taste, but I've encountered works of literature in which things that don't even generally interest me are handled in such a compelling fashion that I'm riveted!

  • 1
I know we've had this conversation before, but I still can't stand it sometimes even if it does further the plot because in those instances, that is the plot. And I'm not in it to see the characters I love basically broken.

In cases where that is the plot, though, I usually consider it gratuitous and purposeless because, in my view, pain for pain's sake does not equal worthwhile narrative. Maybe it is for some, but not for me. My life contains a high enough default anxiety level to begin with. In most cases, I'm not going to learn more by watching the characters I love suffer more than the developmental arc's actual requirements.

Edited at 2014-12-17 07:21 pm (UTC)

By now there's so much I can hardly find a novel I can stand to read.

However, the problem is probably is really that I've read so much fiction in my lifetime it's impossible to engage me with anything. This does happen to avid readers of fiction.

Which is why, finally, what fiction we do read tends to be within the many varieties of what is loosely called mystery fiction. I came to the conclusion some years ago that the mystery is the generic universal solvent -- all genres can be encompassed within mysteries.

Love, C.

However, the problem is probably is really that I've read so much fiction in my lifetime it's impossible to engage me with anything. This does happen to avid readers of fiction.

!!!

For as much as I've read in my life, then, I would've expected this to happen by now - but judging by how raw my reactions are when something really hits the spot, I'm quite sure that this phenomenon is as far outside my experience as a reader as it would be possible for me to get. Do you find that it's a kind of desensitization, or...? Is this a widespread phenomenon? I am fascinated. More things in heaven and earth indeed.

Edited at 2014-12-18 03:22 am (UTC)

  • 1
?

Log in

No account? Create an account